User ID:

Remember me
Lost password?

Will Success Spoil The Napa Valley?

By Charles Olken

There are those who would title an essay on the status of the Napa Valley as “Success Has Spoiled The Napa Valley”. I am not among them, but I get the point.

For years now, I have preferred to take my out of town guests to Sonoma (Town or Valley or further up county) simply because one can see a more relaxed, semi-normal way of life. The Napa Valley is not normal. It is rich, privileged, self-indulgent and self-satisfied. Were it not for the fact that so many brilliant wines are grown there, it would be as easy to ignore as Palm Beach or Newport.

But, there I was last week, tasting my way through a couple of dozen brilliant Cabernets from Oakville in the oh-so handsome oak tank room at the Robert Mondavi Winery. And loving it. Maybe I am also self-indulgent and self-satisfied. Being in the presence of greatness will do that to a person.

So, yes, I get it. There were a ton of very rich, very young people pouring wines that they are their forebears had created, and I was accompanied by several score writers, retailers and sommeliers from all over the country who had flown in for the experience. At least, I am not the only self-indulgent person who drinks good wine.

But the point remains. For the most part, and thankfully not exclusively, these are wines that the average wine geek is not going to drink save for the exception when someone else is paying the tab. Wine everywhere is getting expensive. The wines that I drank regularly in my youth and that filled my cellar are no longer the wines I buy today. I am one of the lucky ones. I got to taste the First Growths of Bordeaux and the Napa Valley in my youth and could afford to put them away.

Today, very few ordinary working stiffs, even educated working stiffs like me before I got into the winewriting business, are buying and tasting those wines. Our wine intelligence level has to be slipping because the new generation of writers and sommeliers simply do not/cannot possess intimate knowledge of the best unless they taste them at large, open bottle events like the one I sat in on last week.

Will success spoil Napa Valley when the only way one can taste Screaming Eagle is stand in a line fifty feet long for a one ounce pour? Is that a learning experience? If not, will the next generation even know what the great wines taste like? It is not their fault, of course. None of us control the laws of supply and demand.

And I suspect that the great wines of Bordeaux, of Oakville, of Burgundy are always going to be out there. But they will no longer be the standards by which wines are judged except by reference—and certainly not by long experience. That problem, the turning of great wine into the Rolls Royces of our vinous times, does in some way hurt us all. But, if we never get to taste Bond or Latour, Mark Aubert or DRC, we will all be a little diminished in the process. That is why there are those who say that success has already spoiled the Napa Valley.


The CGCW Experience - Take the Tour

Meet the New CGCW

For thirty-five years, Connoisseurs’ Guide has been the authoritative voice of the California wine consumer. With readers in all fifty states and twenty foreign countries, the Guide is valued by wine lovers everywhere for its honesty and for it strong adherence to the principles of transparency, unbiased, hard-hitting opinions. Now, it is becoming the California winelover’s most powerful online voice as well. And, our new features provide an unmatched array of advice and information for aficionados of every stripe.


Not So....
by TomHill
Posted on:4/30/2015 5:20:17 PM

Charlie sez: "The Napa Valley is not normal. It is rich, privileged, self-indulgent and self-satisfied."

Awwwwright, Charlie...I'm going to call you on this one.

I get so tired of hearing this charge leveled against NapaVlly folks. This is a gross generalization and you should well know it. You don't have to scratch the surface very deeply to find plenty of folks there  that live in common little bungalows, that have to scrimp to pay their mortgages every month, who have to juggle their lives up the wazoo to get to work at their winemaking or vnyd manager jobs and still get their kids off to school every morning and picked up in the afternoon, who drink a Sonoma Teroldego or Zinfandel every night and have'nt had a ScreamingEagle in yrs, if ever. You saw many of those folks all around you there at RibollaFest a few yrs ago. These are the real folks of the NapaVlly and there are plenty of them there. They just don't show up at tastings of high-end Oakville Cabs.

   True.....the place reeks of $$$'s and I, as well, am very off-put by many of the glitzy tasting rooms and high-end showcase wineries. But, exactly as in LasVegas, there are plenty of "real" folks in the NapaVlly if you just look around. And I'm sure you know many of them.

   And, true, there are many of those NapaVlly Cabs that I will never drink...unless someone gifts me a taste of them. But I've turned my back on NapaVlly Cabs many yrs ago, primarily because of the $$'s charged for them, and have never looked back. A NapaVlly Refosco suits me just fine.

End of rant.



by Charlie Olken
Posted on:4/30/2015 9:33:07 PM

Hello Tom--

You are, of course, right, but your later comments prove the real point of the essay. Napa Valley wines at the top end have become pricey to the point of being exclusionary to those who are not loaded. Napa is certainly not alone in that phenomenon not in the lead, but it is a disappointing state of affairs that the only way even wine geeky folks can ever taste the top wines is eithery by the thimbleful or on someone else's largesse.

That state of affairs does not diminish the Napa Valley but it does diminish the ability of folks to learn what greatness is all about. 

by TomHill
Posted on:5/1/2015 7:03:14 AM

Yup, that latter point I can only agree. Your original statement just pushed one of my buttons.

   I'd long ago abandoned any hope of tasting the very best wines from Burgundy or Bordeaux. I've also added NapaVlly Cab to that list as well. Tain't losing any sleep over it.



Leave a comment below, but please limit your comments to 1,200 characters or less. We find it helpful to make a copy of our comments to be sure that they fit. In that way, you can edit them if they run long.

(Please note: your e-mail address will not be visible after posting)



Note: Refresh your browser to see your latest comments.

Having technical problems with the comment system? Click here.